Is Addiction a Choice or a Disease?

By Dr. Adi Jaffe

A never-ending debate among treatment professionals is over whether addiction is a choice or a disease.

Some say those who engage in substance abuse are in complete control over their actions. That’s the “choice and personal responsibility” theory. Others disagree. They feel the substance abuser has no control over this kind of harmful behavior. They believe the biology of addicts compels them to seek drugs.  They follow the “neuroscience and disease” model. Which one is right?

Well, they both are. Habit formation and substance use are often intertwined.

With my clients, I typically like using the act of crossing the street as an example. In the United States, people look to the left before they cross the street. Why? Because our society taught us to do so. Over time, this pattern of looking left, right, and left again, becomes an automatic response, wired into the brain, that prevails over all other decision making efforts. In neuroscience we call this a “prepotent response.”

But looking to the left is the wrong response in a country where people drive on the other side of the road (like England). If you moved to such a country, you’d have to change your habit, which isn’t easy. It would require deliberate action (the decision to change) and ongoing practice (diligence). Only then could the brain rewire itself and create a new automatic response—and even that would take time. In the meantime, you’d be stuck with a habit that is dangerous to your survival but difficult to break.

Is addiction a choice or a disease?

How does this apply to the argument of whether addiction is a choice or a disease?

Substance use often begins as a simple rewarding experience, which through repetition and the rewiring of the brain’s learning and reward circuits can become habitual. If that habit escalates into problematic substance use, we can end up with something that our society has called addiction. Changing that automatic response would require a similar approach to the one it took to adjust our ritual of crossing the street: deliberate action (the decision to break the habit) and ongoing training (diligent adherence to a treatment program). Eventually, the brain would rewire itself and create a new, healthier automatic response.

You may have noticed something missing from that discussion, namely judgment. At Alternatives, we don’t wonder why clients behave the way they do any more than we wonder why they look left when crossing the street. In the end it comes down to learning, and if we want to end up with a different set of behaviors, we have to understand the mechanisms and processes that got us there and lay the groundwork for making a change.

Like I said, un-learning an automatic response isn’t easy. But it can be done. The brain is highly adaptable. If you work with it rather than against it, the brain will respond favorably.

Click here to learn more about our services or contact us directly at DrKern@AlternativesBH.com or DrJaffe@AlternativesBH.com

COMMENTS

  1. These idiots that clamor that addiction is a “disease” believe that by saying it long enough and loud enough, that that somehow makes it true! What these “disease” proponents neglect are TWO very important details:
    1.) What the MEDICAL CRITERIA of “disease” is, and 2.) HOW this thing called “addiction” meets that criteria! Then there is the small FACT of HOW people with addictions CHOOSE THEIR ADDICTIONS (after all, HOW does the addictive liquid, sold, or gas get into the ingestor again?). Ask someone with cancer, HIV, high blood pressure or diabetes if they get to CHOOSE that medical condition on a daily basis, or get to choose WHEN it manifests itself! The “disease theory” is just that-a THEORY, and a pathetic one at that! I can’t think of anything worse to tell addicts who have PhD’s in evasion of responsibility that their addiction is somehow “not their fault” because of an alleged “disease” that they willingly, knowingly, and voluntarily gave to themselves!

    - atheisticallyyours88

    Reply

  2. The “addiction is a learning disorder” argument/theory is laid out in minute detail in the book, “The Unbroken Brain” by Maia Szalavitz

    - Atheisticallyyours

    Reply

LEAVE A COMMENT

Your email is never published or shared